Berger
Lisa McClain
9/9/12
Summary
-Berger talks about surveyor and surveyed, how woman are
both. He shows through the painting that women were showed as just object, how
they there just used in painting for the surveyor (men). They did this by how
they positioned the women in the painting, when they even put a male in the
painting they had her looking away from him as in daring someone better to come
along. They mostly had them positioned to look at there surveyor and have
themselves lay or sit openly to them, unless the painter himself feels he cant
even pretend she is wanting him and have her looking away wanting another
person, with a light hitting her.
Questions
for Discussion and Journaling
-Iv
seen women advertising in perfume ads and clothing magazines mostly. The images
iv seen and Berger talks about are similar by how the women look at the
“surveyor” and turned towards you so you can see what there trying to sell. But
with perfume ads if its men cologne then the women mostly look towards the man
in the advertising with them with adoring stairs. I think the images have
changed over time, the poses the women are in have changed and they seam a
little more covered.
Applying
and Exploring Ideas
- I don’t think
that in modern day the women are positioned the same because there more loss
and not so stiffly looking and not just laying or sitting, now the women or
taken in motion or with other things. There just not in a bed naked to be used
for just purely seduction, and photos meant for that the girls have a lighter
background and not all dark.
Meta
Moment
-I feel like it
was meant to challenge us, its suppose to make us think and analyzed how society
use to have perspective of women. Also how things are positioned for use to get
certain thoughts or prospects. I think we were reading this so we get the idea
of how if you put something a certain way can make all the difference.
Berger: Very good, Lisa. This is your best and most insightful RR to date. You seem to jump into this mix of ideas presented to you by Berger and wrestle meaning from them, especially in your discussion of the surveyor and the surveyed in your summary. In your summary, I think you might want to tie in how Berger makes the leap from European oil painting to the culture in which we live, here and now. Also, try to identify who you think the intended audience is. I enjoyed your “meta-moment” as well, in that you work in an attempt to figure out why we are reading this for a writing class, and your result, “perspective,” is definitely a reason that Berger applies to writing.
ReplyDelete